In a multi-center study conducted in Great Britain and Australia, 86 adults with mental retardation (IQ < 75) and aggressive behavior were randomized to double-blind treatment with Risperdal (mean dose, 1.8 mg/day), Haldol (mean dose, 2.9 mg/day), or placebo. The primary outcome was score on the modified overt aggression scale (MOAS) at 4 weeks. The results were that placebo reduced the MOAS score by more than either of the active treatments, with the difference close to being statistically significant (p=.07 vs. Risperdal and p=.06 vs. Haldol) (Tyrer P, et al., Lancet 2008;371(9606):57-63).
TCPR’s Take: These results are differ- ent from some prior studies which showed a benefit of Risperdal in this population. One likely reason is that past studies included a “placebo run-in” phase, in which patients who responded rapidly to placebo were excluded from the double-blind study. This had the effect of minimizing the placebo effect in the main study and increasing the likelihood of a drug vs. placebo difference. These investigators did not include the placebo run-in in order to make the design more similar to clinical practice. These results imply that in aggressive mentally retarded adults, placebo effects are extremely powerful, and perhaps prescribing a multivitamin (with great fanfare and high expectations) is as effective as prescribing an antipsychotic, with far fewer side effects.
Please see our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, Subscription Agreement, Use of Cookies, and Hardware/Software Requirements to view our website.
© 2024 Carlat Publishing, LLC and Affiliates, All Rights Reserved.